About this Journal Publication ethics Editorial Board Editorial Council Editorial Office For the Authors Contacts

News feeds

Journal in Databases

eLIBRARY.RU - ═└ËÎ═└▀ Ţ╦┼╩Ďđ╬══└▀ ┴╚┴╦╚╬Ď┼╩└

Google Scholar

Google Scholar

For authors' attention

Publication is free of charge

In aims to provide interconnection of publications in international scientific journals using Digital Object Identification - DOI, our editorial office incorporated the journal "Social aspects of population health" into international reference system CrossRef.

Since 2016 DOI will be assigned to all scientific articles published in our journal free of charge.

Also DOI will be assigned to all articles published in 2014 and 2015 free of charge as well
Main arrow Archive of previous Issues arrow ╣5 2012 (27) arrow Basic techniques and real practice of rating evaluation in public health
Basic techniques and real practice of rating evaluation in public health Print
Tuesday, 11 December 2012

T.A. Siburina1, A.A.Knyazev1, L.K. Lokhtina1, Yu.V. Miroshnikova2
Federal Research Institute for Health Organization and Informatics of Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation, Moscow
2Federal medical biological agency of Russia, Moscow

Summary. Rating evaluation is currently being used in various economic branches and in social life. It is based on cardinal indicators and implies optimization of management. Techniques of rating evaluation, however, is still at store, the general notion prevailing, that evaluation is made for comparing subjects of the same type, but the calculation of it being sophisticated and consisting of numerous components.

The purpose of a rating project usually predetermines approach choice, formulas of calculation to be implemented, and a set of indicators.

Unification of all these parameters is a main prerequisite for the practice of comparison of subjects of the same type. The type of techniques of rating evaluation to be implemented is determined with concern to the type of studied subjects and purposes of management regulation at store which is really based on comparable data only. It is adapted and perfected along these outlined pathways.

Experts determination on the weight of every one of the indicators is indispensable in rating evaluation. Thus, the final evaluation is made not only judging from the magnitude of an indicator as it is (be it score, coefficient or deviation from standard or pattern value), but on the basis of its relative significance. Rating evaluation also must take into account the vector of an indicator being either positive or negative.

Integral rating evaluation of candidates to join senior staff was elaborated in our previous studies, and it includes four clusters of parameters pertaining to personality of a candidate, to career achievements and business style. Experts weighing of every indicator/cluster of indicators was performed, and it was done taking in account the very gist of the post-in-question.

Integral rating evaluation of candidates most fit for the post requirements was paralleled by their selection by an ad-hoc experts board of regional level, and our approach was factually approved in this process of forming reserve bank of senior staff of public health to enter ôprofessional squad of the nationö.

Keywords. Rating evaluation; integral indicator; reserve of senior staff.


  1. Bakanov M.I., Melnik M.V., Sheremet A.D. Teoriya ekonomicheskogo analiza. Uchebnik [The theory of economic analysis. Textbook]. Bakanov M.I. editor. 5th rev. ed. Moscow: Finansy i statistika; 2005. 536 p.
  2. Beshelev S.D., Gurvich F.G. Matematiko-statisticheskiye metody ekspertnykh otsenok [Mathematical and statistical methods of expert assessments]. Moscow: Statistika; 1980. 203 p.
  3. Bushuyeva G.A., Polzik Ye.V., Tyukov Yu.A. Nekotoryye podkhody k otsenke effektivnosti ekonomicheskoy deyatelnosti meditsinskikh uchrezhdeniy [Some approaches to assessing the efficiency of economical activity of healthcare facilities]. Ekonomika zdravookhraneniya 2000;42(2):39-41.
  4. Vyalkov A.I. Teoreticheskoye obosnovaniye i razrabotka osnov regionalnoy politiki v zdravookhranenii [Theoretical grounds and development of the basis for regional healthcare policy]. [PhD. Thesis]. Moscow. 1999. 35p.
  5. Gaydarov S.M., Smirnov S.N. Organizatsiya platnoy meditsinskoy deyatelnosti v lechebno-profilakticheskikh uchrezhdeniyakh [Organization of paid medical service in healthcare facilities]. Irkutsk. IGMU. 1999. 132 p.
  6. Gasnikov V.K. O metodologicheskikh problemakh razvitiya informatizatsii upravleniya v zdravookhranenii [On methodological problems in development of computerization in healthcare management]. Vrach i informatsionnyye tekhnologii 2004;(1):4-11.
  7. Doklad o sostoyanii zdravookhraneniya v mire 2000 g. Sistemy zdravookhraneniya: uluchsheniye deyatelnosti [The World Health Report 2000. Health Systems: Improving Performance]. [Internet]. 2000 [cited 2012 May 5]. Available from: http://www.who.int/whr/2000/en/whr00_ru.pdf
  8. Kiryanov B.F., Tokmachev M.S. Postroyeniye integralnykh pokazateley otsenki zdorovya naseleniya s uchetom chuvstvitelnosti etikh pokazateley [Development of integral indicators of population health with a view to sensibility to these indicators]. In: Materialy nauchnoy sessii NNTs SZO RAMN. Moscow: Meditsina; T. 2. 2003. P. 40-45.
  9. Korablev V.I. Soderzhaniye ekonomicheskogo analiza v zdravookhranenii [The content of economic analysis in healthcare]. Ekonomika zdravookhraneniya 2002;(4):5-8.
  10. Koretskiy I.V. Integralnaya otsenka potentsiala obshchestvennogo zdorovya i osnovnykh resursov sistemy zdravookhraneniya [An integral assessment of public health potential and the main healthcare resources]. [PhD. Thesis]. Moscow. 2004. 162 p.
  11. Korobkova O.K. Reyting ekonomicheskoy i lechebnoy deyatelnosti uchrezhdeniy zdravookhraneniya [Rating of economic and clinical activity of healthcare facilities]. Moscow: Poligraficheskiy izdatelskiy tsentr ╣1; 2002. 148p.
  12. Korobkova O.K. Upravleniye uslugami uchrezhdeniy zdravookhraneniya na osnove reytingovoy otsenki ikh deyatelnosti [Managing service provided by healthcare facilities on the base of rating assessment]. Moscow: Megalion; 2003. 164 p.
  13. Lindenbraten A.L., Shipova V.M. Organizatsionno-metodicheskiye printsipy vnedreniya sistem materialnogo stimulirovaniya meditsinskogo personala [Organization and methodical principles in implementation of financial encouragement of medical personal]. In: Organizatsiya meditsinskoy pomoshchi naseleniyu v usloviyakh reformirovaniya zdravookhraneniya. Collection of scientific studies. Blagoveshchensk. 2008. P. 43-46.
  14. Medvedskaya D.R., Polzik Ye.V., Nikiforov S.A., Kazantsev V.S. K probleme opredeleniya reytinga munitsipalnykh sistem zdravookhraneniya [To the problem of determining the rating of municipal health care systems]. Ekonomika zdravookhraneniya 2010;(8):27-32.
  15. Medik V.A., Tokmachev M.S., Fishman B.B. Statistika v meditsine i v biologii: Rukovodstvo v 2-kh tomakh [Statistics in medicine and biology: Guidelines in 2 volumes]. T. 1. Theoretical statistics. Moscow: Meditsina; 2000. 346 c.
  16. Medik V.A., Tokmachev M.S. Modelirovaniye integralnykh pokazateley otsenki zdorovya naseleniya [Modeling of integral indicators of population health status]. Zdravookhraneniye RF 2003;(3):17-20.
  17. Polyakov I.V., Lisanov A.G, Matsko G.M. O territorialnoy sisteme upravleniya kachestvom meditsinskoy pomoshchi [On territorial system of healthcare quality management] Ekonomika zdravookhraneniya 1996;(2):22-24.
  18. Prikaz Ministerstva zdravookhraneniya respubliki Tatarstan ot 31.03.2011 ╣345. "O naznachenii otvetstvennykh lits" ["On appointment of decision-makers", the Order of the Ministry of Health of Republic of Tatarstan] [Internet]. 2011 [cited 2012 Jun 10]. Available from: http://www.regionz.ru/index.php?ds=1026369
  19. Prikaz Ministerstva zdravookhraneniya Ulyanovskoy oblasti ╣935 ot 29.11.2011g. "Ob utverzhdenii pokazateley i organizatsii reytingovoy otsenki deyatelnosti meditsinskikh organizatsiy gosudarstvennoy sistemy zdravookhraneniya Ulyanovskoy oblasti" ["On approving the indicators and organization of rating assessment of health facilities in the state healthcare system of Ulyanovsk region", the Order of the Ministry of Health of Ulyanovsk region]. [Internet]. 2011 [cited 2012 Jun 10]. Available from: http://www.med.ulgov.ru/deyatelnost/1025.html
  20. Rasporyazheniye Gubernatora Khabarovskogo kraya ot 15 yanvarya 2008 g. N 8-r "Ob utverzhdenii pokazateley otsenki effektivnosti deyatelnosti sistemy zdravookhraneniya Khabarovskogo kraya" ["On approving indicators of efficiency of healthcare system in Khabarovsk territoryĺ, the Regulation of the Governor of Khabarovsk Territory of 2008, January 15, N 8-­.] [Internet]. 2008 [cited 2012 Jun 10] Available from: http://khabarovsk.news-city.info/docs/sistemsr/dok_iernoi.htm
  21. Siburina T.A., Attayeva L.Zh. Povysheniye effektivnosti upravleniya zdravookhraneniyem na osnove ispolzovaniya sovremennykh personal-tekhnologiy [Rising efficiency of healthcare management by using modern personal-technologies]. Kremlevskaya meditsina 2009;(1):25-28.
  22. Tropnikova V.Ye. Effektivnost ispolzovaniya resursov v regionalnom zdravookhranenii [Efficiency of implementation of resources in region healthcare]. [PhD. Thesis]. Moscow; 2004. 24 p.
  23. Khalfin R. A., Volkov S. N., Gribanova T. N., Yermakov S. P. Sovershenstvovaniye sistemy zdravookhraneniya s ispolzovaniyem monitoringa zdorovya naseleniya [Improving the healthcare system on the base of population health monitoring]. Ekaterinburg; 1997. 99 p.
  24. Tsybin A.K., Glushanko V.S., Kolosova T.V. Integralnaya otsenka effektivnosti meditsinskikh tekhnologiy: Metodicheskie rekomendatsii. [Integral assessment of efficiency of medical technologies: Methodical recommendations].Minsk: Vitebskiy gosudarstvennyy meditsinskiy universitet; 2000. 25 p.
  25. Chavpetsov V.F., Karachevtseva M.A., Mikhaylov S.M., Pakhomov A.V., Bogushevich N.M., Gurinov P.V. Opredeleniye reytingov uchrezhdeniy zdravookhraneniya i rayonov Sankt-Peterburga na osnovanii rezultatov deyatelnosti po upravleniyu kachestvom meditsinskoy pomoshchi. Metodicheskiye rekomendatsii [Determination of ratings of healthcare facilities and regions of St. Petersburg on the base of results of health care quality management. Methodical recommendations]. Menedzhment kachestva v sfere zdravookhraneniya i sotsialnogo razvitiya 2011;10(4):141-148.
  26. Sheremet A.D., Sayfulin R.S. Metodika finansovogo analiza [Methodic of financial analysis]. Moscow: INFRA-M; 1995. 176 p.
  27. Yurgel N.V. Nikonov Ye.L., Saverskiy A.V. Pervyye rezultaty sostavleniya obshcherossiyskogo reytinga roddomov [The first results of development of the all-Russia rating of maternity hospitals]. Zdravookhraneniye 2009;(8):36-55.
  28. Entsiklopediya reytingov: ekonomika, obshchestvo, sport [An encyclopedia of ratings: economy, society, and sport]. Karminskiy A.M., Polozov A.A., Yermakov S.P. Moscow: Ekonomicheskaya gazeta; 2011. 349 p.
  29. Groene O. PATH- Performance Assessment Tool for quality improvement in Hospitals. WHO Europe 2006. [Internet]. 2006 [cited 2012 Jun 18]. Available from: http://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0009/99819/E88584.pdf
  30. Bossert T., Bärnighausen T., Bowser D., Mitchell A., Gedik G. Otsenka finansirovaniya, obrazovaniya, upravleniya i politicheskogo konteksta dlya strategicheskogo planirovaniya kadrovykh resursov zdravookhraneniya. VOZ. 2009.[Assessment of financing, education , management, and political context for strategic planning of human health resources. WHO. 2009] [Internet]. 2009 [cited 2012 Jun 10]. Available from: http://www.who.int/hrh/tools/assess_financing_ru.pdf

Views: 18767

Be first to comment this article

Write Comment
  • Please keep the topic of messages relevant to the subject of the article.
  • Personal verbal attacks will be deleted.
  • Please don't use comments to plug your web site. Such material will be removed.
  • Just ensure to *Refresh* your browser for a new security code to be displayed prior to clicking on the 'Send' button.
  • Keep in mind that the above process only applies if you simply entered the wrong security code.

Code:* Code

Last Updated ( Monday, 17 December 2012 )
Next >
home contact search contact search